Skip to main content
Cintia  Rodriguez
  • Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Facultad de Psicología
  • http://www.uam.es/gruposinv/deteduca/equipo.html
Executive functions (EFs) embrace a range of cognitive control processes that allow us to control and direct our own behavior, thoughts, and emotions and to develop complex responses to difficulties. Standardized tasks commonly used to... more
Executive functions (EFs) embrace a range of cognitive control processes that allow us to control and direct our own behavior, thoughts, and emotions and to develop complex responses to difficulties. Standardized tasks commonly used to investigate EFs are reviewed. Here, a study is reported of the first challenges that children set for themselves in everyday life situations from the end of the first year in the 0–1 classroom of various early years schools. The influence of educational situations, based on the possibilities of action that the teachers offered the children, and the materiality made available were analyzed. It was found that the children faced challenges from the end of the first year of life. These challenges involved the everyday uses of objects and instruments, uses which were difficult and significative for them: (i) rhythmic-sonorous canonical uses, (ii) canonical uses, and (iii) symbolic uses. These challenges were identified in structured and semi-structured educational situations in which the children could choose the objects, what to do with them and how.
The two first years of life are critical in the development of Executive Functions (EF). However, very little is known about their early manifestations, how they develop, how they relate to other psychological constructions or the... more
The two first years of life are critical in the development of Executive Functions (EF).
However, very little is known about their early manifestations, how they develop, how
they relate to other psychological constructions or the status of other people’s influence
in this early development. The study of EFs has been carried out through standardised
tasks, but some authors question their ecological validity and suggest an approach
involving everyday situations and the challenges that children set for themselves. In this
article we first review these issues in relation to the first manifestations of EFs. We
secondly present a longitudinal case study at nursery school of a child between the ages
of 8 and 17 months, considering the challenges and the means he employed in order to
resolve them. We found that, from 8 months of age, the child gave himself challenges
in relation to the functional uses of objects and instruments. He regulated his own
behavior both through object and instrument uses and private gestures. He also
involved the teacher at 17 months. This finding suggests that (1) the material world
is particularly important in these early manifestations of EF, (2) teachers’ interventions
are essential. Implications of the findings for early years education are discussed.
Conceptual metaphor theory showed, from embodiment, the importance of metaphor as a cognitive process. This influential theory assumes the existence of primitive but powerful mental structures called image schemas. In this paper, we... more
Conceptual metaphor theory showed, from embodiment, the importance of metaphor as a cognitive process. This influential theory assumes the existence of primitive but powerful mental structures called image schemas. In this paper, we conduct a critical inquiry about these structures from the developmental perspective of the pragmatics of the object and show they have serious problems. Taking the CONTAINER image schema as a case, we discuss the plausibility of image schemas in early childhood. We suggest that children do not interact with objects as if a basic and generic CONTAINER cognitive structure preexisted. Instead, in everyday life, they use “container” objects to fulfill very different functions. As object function is construed by children's participation in triadic child-adult-object experiences through semiotic mediation, we propose image schemas are not natural or direct, do not exist in early childhood, and are a developmental, pragmatic, and cultural product. As empirical illustration, we analyze a child-mother-objects interaction at home.
From the end of the first year children begin to self-regulate their own behaviour. Executive Functions are already present. This paper shows evidence — from a longitudinal case study carried out at an infant school — of the beginnings... more
From the end of the first year children begin to self-regulate their
own behaviour. Executive Functions are already present. This paper shows
evidence — from a longitudinal case study carried out at an infant school —
of the beginnings of the functional use of a spoon by an 11-month-old child
through self-regulatory processes with non-linguistic semiotic systems. These
involve (1) private gestures including (a) ostensive, (b) pointing, (c) symbolic
and (d) emotional gestures; (2) attempts at grasping; and (3) proto-canonical
uses of the spoon. This self-regulation process is enhanced by the educational
intervention of the teacher who demonstrates its use, invites, re-orientates and
evaluates the child’s entry into spoon uses.

Keywords: private ostensive gestures; private pointing gestures; private
proto-canonical uses; Executive Functions; teacher educational actions
For decades, the literature on the emergence of triadic interactions considers the end of the first year of life as the time when children become able to communicate with others intentionally about a referent. Prior to that, children only... more
For decades, the literature on the emergence of triadic interactions considers the end of the first year of life as the time when children become able to communicate with others intentionally about a referent. Prior to that, children only relate in dyads, either with someone else or with an object. However, several researchers claim that referents are not naturally given in human communication and that they need to be established in interaction with others. In this study, we focus on earlier triadic interactions initiated by adults, when young babies still require an adult to bring the material world within their reach. In these early triadic interactions , ostensive gestures (with the object in the hand) are one of the first means of enabling the establishment of shared reference. Such gestures are easier to understand since sign (gesture) and referent (object) coincide. We conducted a longitudinal study with 6 babies filmed at 2, 3 and 4 months old in interaction with their mothers and a sounding object (a maraca). We analyzed different communicative initiatives by the adult and the child's responses. The results show that children come to understand the adult's communicative intention gradually through interaction. Adults include children in organized communicative " niches " based on ostensive actions, both through ostensive gestures and demonstrations of the use of the object. Consequently, the first shared understandings between adult and child take place around the object and its uses. Rhythm is a powerful tool used to structure the interaction. Eventually, adults provide space to children to actively interact with the sounding object themselves. These results highlight the importance of considering ostensive actions as a communicative tool that favors joint attention and action. They also bring some light to the interdependence between a child who actively perceives and acts, and the structured situation that the adult organizes for them.
In developmental psychology pointing gestures are widely accepted as the gesture that par excellence allows shared reference ( Cyrulnik, 2002; Liszkowski, Carpenter, Striano, & Tomasello, 2006), and as the basic form of gestural reference... more
In developmental psychology pointing gestures are widely accepted as the gesture that par excellence allows shared reference ( Cyrulnik, 2002; Liszkowski, Carpenter, Striano, & Tomasello, 2006), and as the basic form of gestural reference ( Leavens, Hopkins & Bard, 2008; Pika, 2008). However, in semiotics, it is ostensive gestures that are considered to be the first instance of active signification, that is, gestures where an object occupies a prominent place as an instrument of communication ( Eco, 1976). In this paper, coming from the pragmatics of the object perspective ( Rodríguez & Moro, 1998), we argue that it is not pointing but ostensive gestures that come first. Specifically, we argue that: (1) ostensive gestures are gestures; (2) a developmental understanding of gestures suggests that children understand and produce ostensive gestures before pointing gestures, and adults produce ostensive gestures with objects in a shared space with the child at a very early age long before pointing gestures; (3) a theoretical and pragmatic conceptualization of objects beyond their “physical” level is required. Objects are cultural products with public functions; as a consequence, objects are also powerful instruments of communication between people, especially during the first years of life, and not simply the setting that surrounds the communicative event. Finally, we discuss the implications of these notions for developmental psychology, going beyond the declarative and imperative functions. We discuss three new functions of ostensive gestures: (1) for oneself with an exploratory and/or contemplative function, (2) private with a self-regulatory function in order to solve a problem, and (3) to another with an interrogative function.
Adults mediate the relationship between material reality and children, according to functional units of cultural relevance. This paper explores early development of semiotic systems in infants, analyzing rhythmic, sonorous and melodic... more
Adults mediate the relationship between material reality and children, according to functional units of cultural relevance. This paper explores early development of semiotic systems in infants, analyzing rhythmic, sonorous and melodic components, which enable adult-child interaction with and about objects. The triads (with sonorous and non-sonorous objects) was studied longitudinally at age 2, 4 and 6 months. We propose that rhythmic, sonorous and melodic components conformed one of the basic semiotic systems upon the adult's action relies (through gestures and uses of objects) in order to segment and organize objects in the world. Likewise, children actively respond to these presentations and seek sounds for themselves when they are able to interact with the object more autonomously.
Since the 80s, numerous laboratory investigations have been arguing that infants are numerically competent. This work presents a critical review of this line of research. We propose that despite the repertoire of numerical abilities... more
Since the 80s, numerous laboratory investigations have been arguing that infants are numerically competent. This work presents a critical review of this line of research. We propose that despite the repertoire of numerical abilities attributed to infants and the seemingly natural character of the very first numbers in the numerical series, the semiotic complexity of their use and comprehension poses a cognitive challenge that children undertake, motivated, supported and often guided by others. This challenge involves a high degree of semiotic organisation of the material world as well as an ability to manage early sign systems, systems which children learn how to use during their first years of life and which form the platform on which numbers are based.
Alex Gillespie and Flora Cornish draw on the dialogic turn as they consider that, in order to interpret the meaning of an utterance, it is necessary to emphasize its contextual nature. Among other aspects, they address what context is and... more
Alex Gillespie and Flora Cornish draw on the dialogic turn as they consider that, in order to interpret the meaning of an utterance, it is necessary to emphasize its contextual nature. Among other aspects, they address what context is and what is being done while speaking. Taking these two issues as point of departure, it is worth pondering on (1) what revolves around language and what the status of nonlinguistic semiotic systems is for the philosophers of language, (2) Umberto Eco’s critique of the Philosophy of Language, which has not problematized the pre-linguistic relationship with things, and (3) how ontogenesis may shed light on this scheme where linguistic and nonlinguistic aspects are inevitably interrelated. I will reflect on the pragmatic aspects in adult-child communication at its pre-linguistic level. I will underscore the key role played by the object as a complex referent and as a tool for communication.
Adults mediate the relationship between material reality and children, according to functional units of cultural relevance. This paper explores early development of semiotic systems in infants, analyzing rhythmic, sonorous and melodic... more
Adults mediate the relationship between material reality and children, according to functional units of cultural relevance. This paper explores early development of semiotic systems in infants, analyzing rhythmic, sonorous and melodic components, which enable adult-child interaction with and about objects. The triads (with sonorous and non-sonorous objects) was studied longitudinally at age 2, 4 and 6 months. We propose that rhythmic, sonorous and melodic components conformed one of the basic semiotic systems upon the adult's action relies (through gestures and uses of objects) in order to segment and organize objects in the world. Likewise, children actively respond to these presentations and seek sounds for themselves when they are able to interact with the object more autonomously.
Symbolic uses of objects originate in communicative and triadic contexts (adult - child - object). In this longitudinal study we explore the emergence and development of the first symbolic uses in triadic interaction contexts in a girl... more
Symbolic uses of objects originate in communicative and triadic contexts (adult - child - object). In this longitudinal study we explore the emergence and development of the first symbolic uses in triadic interaction contexts in a girl with Down syndrome between 12 and 18-months of age. We conducted five sessions of video recording, at 12, 13 ½, 15, 16 ½, and 18 months chronological age. At each session we videotaped the girl and her mother interacting with different objects. Data were coded in semiotic categories used in previous studies (Rodríguez & Moro, 1999) and a microgenetic analysis was conducted for each session. The first symbolic uses by the girl appeared at 13 ½ months. Symbols were of different types and levels of complexity, and the adult had an important role in facilitating the production of these symbols.
In this study, we address the construction of the first symbolic uses of objects in contexts of triadic interaction (adult– child– object). We assume that symbolic productions are based on public rules of the use of objects previously... more
In this study, we address the construction of the first symbolic uses of objects in contexts of triadic interaction (adult– child– object). We assume that symbolic productions are based on public rules of the use of objects previously agreed by the community. The first symbols are not rooted in any literal, evident reality, but in shared rules of uses about the material world. We observed six dyads communicating and interacting together with 10 objects in a semi-structured situation longitudinally from 9 to 15 months of age. We found that the infants gradually constructed symbolic meanings, and we identified five symbolic levels and sublevels. At 9 months, the infants attended and engaged in the symbolic uses produced by an adult even though they themselves were not yet able to produce them. At 12 months, infants began to use objects symbolically to communicate with adults. The highest percentage of these first symbolic uses was of level 1, that is, with a close relation to the conventional use of the object used to perform the symbol. At 15months, children increased their symbolic uses and performed symbolic uses at all levels, whereas adults reduced such practices. Adult semiotic mediation and the social meanings of objects can be considered important factors in children’ s symbolic productions.
—D. M. Chirico, Choice "[Q]uietly and persistently, Piaget's constructs remain influential through the work of numerous researchers. This refreshing volume looks at the work of those heirs to controversy, picking up the threads since... more
—D. M. Chirico, Choice "[Q]uietly and persistently, Piaget's constructs remain influential through the work of numerous researchers. This refreshing volume looks at the work of those heirs to controversy, picking up the threads since Piaget's death. The volume presents fundamental Piagetian concepts of evidence-based manner, indicating how these play a vital role for the developing person. An important chapter on dialectical constructivism reminds readers that Piaget is the vital link between rationalism and empiricism for cognitive science, setting the stage for future scholars to fill the gaps. Each chapter provides a thorough exploration of some aspect of the Piagetian system. Jaan Valsiner sums it up in the preface: "Piaget's ideas are wandering all over the world as they remain fresh in their richness" . . . Highly recommended."
The later Wittgenstein’s emphasis on the social usage of language has been very influential in psychology, particularly in language acquisition research. This move toward a pragmatic position should also be applied to gestures in... more
The later Wittgenstein’s emphasis on the social usage of language has been very influential in psychology, particularly in language acquisition research. This move toward a pragmatic position should also be applied to gestures in pre-linguistic children and to objects in the everyday contexts of use. The shared ‘forms of life’ presupposed by language involve pre-linguistic gestures and material ‘things’. Research on early communication has focused on proto-declarative and proto-imperative gestures. I extend this focus and propose further types of gestures: ‘proto-interrogatives’ – in which children ‘‘ask’’ for help or regulation from adults, and three types of ‘private gestures’ – ostensive, indexical and symbolic – in which children regulate their own behaviour. This diversity of gestures becomes apparent when objects are taken seriously. Wittgenstein’s ‘language-games’ necessarily apply to games with objects and gestures as well: social meaning in all cases is emergent within the context of these ‘sign games’ and ‘circumstances.’
One of the most fascinating phenomena in early development is that babies not only understand signs others direct to them and later use them to communicate with others, but they also come to direct the same signs towards themselves in a... more
One of the most fascinating phenomena in early development is that babies not only understand signs others direct to them and later use them to communicate with others, but they also come to direct the same signs towards themselves in a private way. Private gestures become “tools of thought”. There is a considerable literature about private language, but almost nothing about private gestures. Private gestures pose an intriguing communicative puzzle: they are communicative, but with the self. In this paper we study two types of private gestures (signs) before language: (1) private ostensive gestures and (2) private pointing gestures. We show in a case study of one child between 12 and 18 months of age that both are used with a self-reflexive function, as a way of “thinking” what to do, in order to solve a problem in the conventional use of an object. The private gestures become self-reflexive signs.
The role of language in self-regulation has been widely studied, yet there is little evidence on the role of self-regulation of pre-linguistic semiotic systems in early development. We present a longitudinal design study to explore when... more
The role of language in self-regulation has been widely studied, yet there is little evidence on the role of self-regulation of pre-linguistic semiotic systems in early development. We present a longitudinal design study to explore when and how children begin to refer pre-linguistic signs with a self-regulatory function. We observed four infants interacting with an adult and a complex object at 11, 13 and 15 months of age. We conducted a microgenetic analysis of observations from a semiotic-pragmatic perspective of development and objects (Rodriguez and Moro, 1999). The children used different pre-linguistic private sings to self-regulate their action in the uses of the object (ostensibly without instruments, with instrument, vocalisations to accompany their action and to evaluate them). We describe the categories used to characterise these behaviours (both, used in previous studies and developed in this study), and we analysed observations that illustrate them.
Se presenta un estudio ideográfico de seguimiento de un bebé con riesgo de alteración en el desarrollo. Entre los 9 y los 16 meses de edad se ha registrado en vídeo la conducta espontánea del sujeto en el entorno del hogar en situaciones... more
Se presenta un estudio ideográfico de seguimiento de un bebé con riesgo de alteración en el desarrollo. Entre los 9 y los 16 meses de edad se ha registrado en vídeo la conducta espontánea del sujeto en el entorno del hogar en situaciones de interacción diádica (sujeto-sujeto) y triádica (sujeto-objeto-sujeto). Para el análisis de datos se establecieron 14 categorías observacionales, basadas en la literatura sobre desarrollo típico y desarrollo alterado en los Trastornos del Espectro Autista. Los resultados obtenidos muestran signos de alarma en el desarrollo en todas las edades en las que ha sido estudiado en: seguimiento de mirada, uso de gestos y conductas de atención (y acción) conjunta. Sería muy aconsejable, introducir la categoría de Usos de Objetos: usos no convencionales, convencionales, y atípicos- en los instrumentos para la identificación de los Trastornos del Espectro Autista. Las conclusiones principales señalan la necesidad de seguir ahondando en el conocimiento de conductas discriminativas desde el primer año de vida, capaces de alertar sobre un desarrollo alterado.
This paper discusses the work of Angel Rivière from his first attempts at a semiotic interpretation of early development, under the influence of Leslie or Batesom, until the systematization of this interest for signs built upon Vygotsky's... more
This paper discusses the work of Angel Rivière from his first attempts at a semiotic interpretation of early development, under the influence of Leslie or Batesom, until the systematization of this interest for signs built upon Vygotsky's ideas. Through Rivière's semiotic interpretation, we reflect on some key topics connecting development and prelinguistic signs, such as: the sign as inference, the meaning of signs as a function of its use, the microgenetic analysis of online interaction using signs as tool, signs and intentional communication in triadic interactions and joint action, or the difficult articulation between object and sign use. We also discuss the interest of using a semiotic interpretation with children at risk.
Este artículo examina las diferentes funciones del gesto del niño, en la fase preverbal, consistente en tender un objeto hacia el adulto y cuya intención no es la de dárselo. Entre estas funciones cabe destacar el papel que el adulto... more
Este artículo examina las diferentes funciones del gesto del niño, en la fase preverbal, consistente en tender un objeto hacia el adulto y cuya intención no es la de dárselo. Entre estas funciones cabe destacar el papel que el adulto adopta en tanto que regulador de la acción del niño a partir de la demanda explícita de éste en este sentido, y la convergencia entre el adulto y el niño en cuanto a las significaciones que se le atribuyen al objeto. La unidad de análisis adecuada en esta situación debe de tener en cuenta al adulto, al niño y al objeto, integrados en una totalidad. Cualquier análisis que no tenga en cuenta esta totalidad corre el riesgo de ser parcial.
Research Interests:
Del ritmo al símbolo se dirige hacia los clásicos de la Psicología Evolutiva, Piaget, Wallon y Vygotsky y recuerda la atención que le prestaron a la observación cualitativa, a los procesos, no sólo a los resultados de las conductas, y al... more
Del ritmo al símbolo se dirige hacia los clásicos de la Psicología Evolutiva, Piaget, Wallon y Vygotsky y recuerda la atención que le prestaron a la observación cualitativa, a los procesos, no sólo a los resultados de las conductas, y al análisis semiótico. Se apoya en la idea de Bruner, para quien la comunicación está pragmáticamente orientada. La cultura y la educación son protagonistas de la construcción de la inteligencia desde sus orígenes. Aborda desde la pragmática y la semiótica los grandes temas de la Primera Infancia, tales como la estrecha conexión entre cuerpo, emociones y ritmo, analiza la evolución de los usos de los objetos en contextos cotidianos y cuestiona que la permanencia del objeto esté completamente al margen de sus aspectos funcionales y culturales. Las primeras intenciones no son productos individuales, sino que son prestadas. Los símbolos también son herramientas de comunicación, y los niños no los producen un día por su cuenta, sino que el adulto los ha venido realizando constantemente al comunicarse con ellos. La imitación no puede reducirse a una simple copia. La interacción triádica adulto-niño-objeto a través de los signos ocurre desde el principio de la vida, aunque la comunicación intencional se produzca al final del primer año.
Los objetos no son la fría realidad "física", sino que son protagonistas en muchas ocasiones de la comunicación entre el bebé y los otros antes de la aparición del lenguaje. En este trabajo, en los orígenes de la Pragmática del Objeto, se... more
Los objetos no son la fría realidad "física", sino que son protagonistas en muchas ocasiones de la comunicación entre el bebé y los otros antes de la aparición del lenguaje. En este trabajo, en los orígenes de la Pragmática del Objeto, se explora, a través de un análisis semiótico, el complejo camino comunicativo que el niño recorre entre los 7 y los 13 meses, hasta empezar a usar los objetos de un modo convencional, por su función.
Research Interests: